2005 Concannon Merlot

Sorry, Your Wine Tastes Like Feet

When I go to a tasting room, I assume a few things. I assume they will have those tumbled marble coasters with the winery’s logo on them. I assume I will deal with a handful of people who are there just to drink, and get drunk; I also assume the majority of my fellow tasters won’t be like that.

I also assume that whoever’s pouring, has tasted the freakin’ wine.

Apparently, that last assumption is just too much.

So, to be fair, I’m not convinced that the 2005 Merlot from Concannon Vineyards tastes like what I had on my recent visit to their tasting room. But, then, that is their fault. They poured that glass for me themselves, from a bottle they opened.

It smelled and tasted like feet. Kinda like a locker room, but drier. If this is what Concannon intended for their Merlot, then I feel sorry for Merlot drinkers who intentionally bought the 2005.

All I can hope is that this wasn’t intentional. And if that is the case, then someone needs to get shitcanned, because this bottle never should have made it to the tasting room floor. Or, perhaps, the tasting room floor is exactly where it belonged.

Verdict: D

  • http://www.drinknectar.com/ @nectarwine

    Yikes! Gotta say I love the honesty. Glad you keep it real. I'm sure there could be some lively discussion on whether you should even mention such a poor showing. I wonder if the winery would be willing to open another bottle for you in this case?

    Josh

  • http://weeklywinejournal.com/ @wklywinejournal

    Better check the employees to see if anyone is missing a foot

  • http://notesfromthecellar.com Steve Paulo

    You know, if this had been a bottle I opened myself, I might not have mentioned it. But the point here, to me, was that Concannon themselves (at least, their employee, who reprents them in this case) opened hat bottle and poured it. If it was indeed supposed to taste like this, then I absolutely stand by my review. There is no need to mention the good but ignore the bad.

    Wine is wine, good and bad. I drink some good, I drink some bad, and I write about both.

  • http://notesfromthecellar.com Steve Paulo

    Sounds like a horrible accident in the crush vat…

  • http://twitter.com/HeatherPaulo HeatherPaulo

    Ah the foot wine. Tasted like old gym socks and perhaps the insole of a well-worn shoe. This makes me especially sad since we used to love concannon and even served it at our wedding! I hope the have a better showing next time we go :-)

  • http://notesfromthecellar.com Steve Paulo

    Of course, the 2004 Petite Sirah we had at our wedding is really quite good. Glad I was in a bit of an anti-Merlot phase back in 2007 ;)

  • Pingback: A Creamy, Buttery Chardonnay | Notes From The Cellar